The Business Sensei

The Accidental Leader

As published in Corp! Magazine

Does this sound painfully familiar?

The team leader left the company or was transferred elsewhere. No one knows anything about the new person coming in. Everything is up in the air. It’s almost impossible to get any work done because everyone is too busy wondering what’s going to happen next. Is the team going to be kept together? Will the project be cancelled?

Or how about this situation:

You were just assigned to take over a strong team. The former leader, well-respected by the team, is leaving. When you get there, there is a marked lack of enthusiasm. Everyone smiles and nods, but the suspicion is palpable. No sooner do the first words leave your mouth when you have a sinking feeling that whatever it was you said, it was exactly the wrong thing.

Although it may seem that the difference is which side of story you happen to be on, in reality, the situations aren’t really any different at all. In both cases a once functional team is tossed into a state of chaotic uncertainty. From feeling comfortable and secure, suddenly everyone is wondering if there’s another shoe about to drop.

Oddly enough, when the new leader comes in, the situation often gets worse. Rather than allaying people’s fears, too often those fears are increased. It’s not that the new leader is trying to scare people; it’s just that whatever she says, it just doesn’t seem to come out quite right.

At one company, the new executive director was welcomed with great fanfare. Thus, she was totally unprepared when her modest proposals to improve how the company delivered products ignited a firestorm of protest and resistance. This was a very painful situation, although I was able to help them work things out in the end. Still, though, perhaps we might want to look at a more upbeat scenario.

At another company, the new president decided to try something different. When he took over, he didn’t tell people how things would be; rather, he asked them how things should be. Rather than set deadlines, he asked employees what deadline the previous, successful president would have set for their projects. Rather than set new rules, or even focus on existing rules, he asked people what sort of structure would most help them. Rather than try to Impose His Mark on the organization, he took the time to understand what mark was already there. Rather than fight the natural resistance people have to change, he invited the rest of the company into the change process. The transition ended up going remarkably well. What was even more interesting was that along the way he took a fair bit of heat from his board that he was not “acting like a leader.”

He ended up being one of the best leaders the company ever had. Despite initial beliefs to the contrary, it was no accident. By now, you might even recognize the company.

Most leaders respond to a chaotic situation by trying to impose order. This isn’t necessarily a bad idea, at least in theory. Chaotic situations are unpleasant and without some sort of structure, nothing is going to get done. Despite this, when order is imposed too rapidly, suddenly everyone is fighting for chaos.

The secret to taking over a new team, indeed, to dealing with any team or company in a chaotic situation, is to move slowly. Speed comes from being in the right place at the right time, not from rushing to get things done. When you take the time to find the most serious pain points, the places where people are most scared or most upset, and you resolve those situations, you build the trust you need to succeed.

How do you find those points? Ask the team. Involve them in the process. Don’t impose order; rather, create order.

Are people concerned about deadlines and how changes in product schedules might impact them? Invite them to help set the deadlines. Is product quality an issue? At one training company, the fear was that the changes would compromise the quality of the training being offered, which would, in turn, drive away clients. The solution was to stop fighting about it and instead identify the metrics currently being used to determine quality: both the official ones and the ones that staff members used privately. Once those metrics were brought to everyone’s attention, then the new CEO could help the staff members see how the new training would actually surpass the old training. Sounds simple, but the experience was anything but!

You impose order when you walk into the situation and tell everyone what to do. You create order when you find points of maximum leverage and invite people to suggest the order they want you to provide. The second may be slower, but, paradoxically, it gets you to where you want to go a lot sooner. How will you create order in your organization?

When the CEO Meets Frankenstein

As published in Corp! Magazine

Horror movies follow some fairly predictable tropes: the monster slowly awakens; someone sees it happening, but no one really believes him. As the story unfolds, people go to investigate and are captured, killed, driven mad and so forth. There’s always something terrible going on, and there’s always some helpless innocent caught up in it, acting the way helpless innocents generally act.

Of course, when the helpless innocent doesn’t act as expected, well, that can cause the whole story to change. The classic comedy, “Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein,” is a traditional period horror film, complete with the legendary Bela Lugosi, in which the helpless innocents are Bud Abbott and Lou Costello, acting like, well, Bud Abbott and Lou Costello. This, of course, causes the plot to go flying off the rails, at least as far as Count Dracula’s dastardly plot to reawaken Frankenstein’s monster is concerned.

The key element of a horror film is that our helpless innocents are put into a situation in which they have no idea what to do. As in most situations, when we don’t know what to do, we do what we know how to do. Indeed, successful horror relies on that phenomenon: the terror comes from seeing how our ordinary actions lead deeper and deeper into trouble. Alternately, if those ordinary actions are slightly askew, the horror becomes comedy. In that case, the humor comes from seeing Abbott and Costello responding to a deepening horror by doing what they normally do.

The movie works because the tendency to do what we know how to do is both powerful and universal. Most people, confronted by novel situations, react that way. When there is truly nothing they can do, they attempt to exert control anyway by doing something that they can do. The results are often comedy or horror, depending on perspective and circumstance.

At one nonprofit, the founder of the organization was a man who had started out working in a stockroom. When the organization hit a financial crisis, he fixated on doing inventory. There was simply nothing useful he could do. Rather than feel helpless, he did the thing he could do. This made his board very happy as it kept him busy while they raised money for the organization.

At a high-tech company, a product deadline was threatened by a vendor not delivering a critical software component on schedule. There was nothing that could be done: the entire product was designed around that deliverable. The department head responded to the situation by demanding his employees work long hours, before the vendor delivered. After it was delivered might have made some sense, as the company would need to make up the lost time, but before? The department head had no control over the vendor, so he dealt with the situation by controlling the people around him.

Comedy and horror might be quite enjoyable when viewed from a safe distance, like a movie screen, but are much less fun to be in the middle of. How, though, does a leader avoid having her actions turn the situation into a comedy of errors or frustrating, painful experience for her employees?

The key is to practice dealing with chaos. Consider successful athletes: they learn all the moves and drills of their particular sport. Then they practice by competing against other athletes in order to become comfortable with the unexpected actions of their opponents. Indeed, Judo competition is referred to as “randori,” or “seizing chaos.” Because it’s not possible to predict what strategies people will employ or control what an opponent does, the successful athlete learns to adapt to the situation. Rather than becoming stuck on one response, they become adept at switching strategies to counter their opponents.

Successful leaders need to develop the same skill. It’s not enough to just know the theory of leadership; you also must practice in a chaotic or ambiguous scenario. Sadly, for many leaders, that means practicing on the job. As most athletes learn the hard way if they move straight from drilling to competition, getting used to chaos takes its own practice.

Fortunately, just as athletes have multiple training tools at their disposal to learn to deal with chaos before they enter competition; tools are available for business leaders as well. Predictive scenarios, a type of live action serious game, provide the sort of detailed, ambiguous situations that enable a leader to become comfortable with chaos. Unlike traditional leadership training exercises, there is no one, right answer. Participants need to motivate others, win deals, provide feedback, and execute strategies in a constantly shifting environment. Rather than just talking about leadership, participants need to display leadership and do it well enough to convince others to follow them.

Like the athlete, the leader becomes adept at switching strategies and at managing unpredictable situations. Rather than being trapped by doing what they can, they become able to apply what they know. Instead of comedy or horror, they achieve success. Now, that is something you do want to be in the middle of!

Stephen Balzac is an expert on leadership and organizational development. A consultant, author, and professional speaker, he is president of 7 Steps Ahead (www.7stepsahead.com), an organizational development firm focused on helping businesses to increase revenue and build their client base. Steve is the author of “The 36-Hour Course in Organizational Development,” published by McGraw-Hill and a contributing author to volume one of “Ethics and Game Design: Teaching Values Through Play.” Contact him at steve@7stepsahead.com.